We Lost Netaji Only for Congress (Nehru) & Communist Party

by ultadin | 30/12/2015 10:15 am

We Lost Netaji Only for Congress (Nehru) & Communist Party


1) We Lost Netaji Only for Congress (Nehru) & Communist Party. 1940-1942 Communist Party Wrote To Russia Subhash Bose Fascist & Russia Should Not Support Him & We Indian People Are Supporting To The Congress & Their Supporters TMC / Left Front (Communists)…? Don’t Know Why..?

2)I will sleep with peace today.. Thnx a lot for giving peace to mind. From last few days I was disturbed n cudnt sleep after I watched movie Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose. I would like to thank every member frm Bengal on FB and also frm Our Hero Bose’s family for providing info on our Neta Ji. I m fully hopeful n confident that within a short span of time Our govt wud declassify all files. I request Surya Kumar Bose to remind our PM again abt declassifying files. Till that time we other Indians would put our efforts to get the files declassified. Jai Hind

3) India lost a global leader to the cowardice and stooge called Nehru the bus…d . Nehru not only fu..d around with the British but also ensured that netaji’s heroics remain away from the Indian people . We all must declare Nehru a puppet PM and rewrite history of modern India to give our greatest leader the respect which he got from other countries like Japan , Vietnam , Burma , China , Korea ,germany & others . Jai hind !

4) Bhagawanji (Mahakal),You have given the avtual picture of the affairs relating to the foreign policy of Nehru (on the dictation of USA,UK), particularly with china (chinese were friends of India since thousands of years).Nehru broke this friendship and made china the enimy of India.Nehru had done all these just to keep Netaji away of Indian politics and to keep his chair safe

5)  I feel it always subhash bose is within us.my blood veins flew blood speedly on hearing name of subhash bose.He is the only man who lives in my heart.


6)It is my belief that a person like Netaji is possibly alive today. We are looking forward for his glorious return in his own country as soon as possible. S. K. Sinha

7)I would just like to correct a factual error: Alfred Wagg never said that he had seen Subhas Bose in Saigon. Wagg spent a few days at our house in 1, Woodburn Park, Calcutta in December 1945. He informed my grand father Sarat Chandra Bose in the presence of my father Amiya Nath Bose, that he was a member of the Allied Intelligence Team that was sent to Taipeh from Gen. MacArthur’s base camp to investigate the so-called plane crash. They found no trace of any plane crash during August 1945.

8) Very purpose of Nehru was to follow the commitments he made to Mountbatten (UK) and General Bilovi (USA) on 19-20 March 1946 at Singapore in exchange of his Prime Ministership in a Free India (dominion of British Commonwealth) and Detention of Netaji in USSR. Some of the commitments were: (i) To protect Anglo-American Capital in India (ii) To accept and work for partition of India in order to cut Bengal and Punjab from it where Netaji was having die hard following (iii) Not to pursue any issue related to Netaji or INA and distribute INA money. (iv) To help in giving a base for Anglo-American forces in Tibet , if not possible due to Cina then in Gilgit.(v) To help Anglo-American forces in destabilising China if Communists come to power. In October 1949, Nehru Govt. was having definite information that Netaji has come to China. Since than, Nehru was actively trying to have a vigil on Netaji and activities of Asian Liberation Force situated in Tibet. First he tried to develop a policy of pleasing China apparently but inside story was that he was interested in a fight with China in order to create a mass psyche of Indians against China. It was General Kariyappa in 1950 and General Thimmaiya in 1959 who threatened Nehru to resign if he (Nehru) forced them to attack China. America was continuously pressurising Nehru to bag a war with China and to provide full support in that case.CIA and Chiang Kai Shek agents were operating from Kalimpong in 1959 for supporting a revolt in Tibet. It was after General Thimmaiya, Nehru constituted Indo-Tibet Border Police and actively pursued his Forward policy by setting up posts in areas which were known to be well inside China. Nehru on one hand was confident that Chinese will not react due to Netaji’s influence on Mao and Chou-en Lai as Netaji had helped them heavily in Chinese Civil War in June -July 1946 and had developed a excellent understanding and friendship. Secondly, Nehru was trying to develop Indian psyche against China and thus against Netaji. It surprised world when China had withdrawn after giving a blow to Indian forces in 1962 war and returned to its original position 20 miles away from MacMohan line. China listed and returned whole territory and war material to Indian Generals. Chou-en lai wrote hundreds of letters to Indian Govt. during 1950 to 1962(even amidest war) to resolve Border issue on table with peaceful talks. China was ready to leave Assam as such and provide 3 times land near Nepal and Bhutan in exchange of area in Siyachin and agreeing to Mcmohan line as border but Nehru did not agree and was always in mood to confreont China. I am a Nationalist and not telling these things just to demean Nehru. This is a fact in secret documents and General Brooks(Indian) reports and at many places. Culprit was not China , it was Nehru and Krishana Menon.


(Based on authentic information from Books, Internet


• Japanese held Netaji in highest esteem and they did not want him to be caught as ‘War Criminal’. Japanese also saw Netaji as a person who can do something to improve relation between Japan and Russia and protect their interest in Manchuria.

• With Japanese investments and rich natural resources, Manchuria was developed an industrial powerhouse. It was a large reservoir of Japanese Weapons. That time, Japanese could have thought to give up Japan but not to give up Manchuria because the later was so vital for them, as they had stockpiled large amount of weapons (enough to sustain more than 7,00,000 troops for several years) in hidden remote and hard-to-reach areas all over Manchuria and more than 200 submarines.

• During August 1945, Manchuria had presence of Kwantung Army (Japan), Kuomintang troops of Chiang Kai-shek, groups of People Liberation Army (Communist Party of China) and then Red Army (Russian) took over the command almost without any resistance. Such an area was ideal for Netaji’s future plans as all these groups were at war among themselves, but friendly to Subhas Bose, rather Netaji was seen as a potential mediator between them, as a strong anti-imperialist and pro-Asian Leader.

• Many people will be surprised to learn that the secret diplomatic ties were established between Stalin and Japanese Emperor ‘Hirohito’ during Second World War, through Kato Kachu (an Indian), the Consulate of Provisional Government of Free India (Azad Hind) at Omsk office in Russia established by Netaji in December1944.



17th Aug. 1945 • On 17 August 1945, at Bangkok before flying to Saigon, Netaji, Lt. General Ishoda, Col. Kagawa, Maj. Gen. Bhosle and Lt. Col. Habibur Rehman dicussed how to get Netaji to Russia and some idea of Netaji’s Plan in Russia. Netaji flew from Bangkok at 8 AM and reached Saigon around 11 AM with his Colleagues. General Isoda finalized Netaji’s escape plan with Field Marshal Terauchi at Dalat.

• Field Marshal Count Terauchi, Commander-in-Chief Southern Command of Japanese Quantung Army (starting from Burma, Thiland, China to Manchuria) and close relative of Emperor of Japan – Hirihito, had great respect and affection for Netaji. He instructed General Isoda to help Netaji to reach Russian Occupied Territory in Manchuria on his (Terauchi’s) own responsibility and directed Lt. General Shidei to accompany Netaji. General Shidei, who knew Russian language and Manchurian topography very well, was going to take command of Quantung Army in order to have a peaceful surrender of Japan to Red Army.

• A secret meeting of Netaji, Col. Habibur Rahman and Japanese Generals Isoda and Hachaiya took place behind closed doors in the house of Shri Narain Das, former local chief of IIL, to workout details of the PLAN. The rest of the INA officials were not privy to the content or subject of that meeting. Netaji’s further plan, to reach Russia through Manchuria and declaration of plane crash to be announced later, was decided in this meeting. It was also decided that General Shidei will look after Netaji up to Dairen.

• Netaji gave a written message to John Thivy of Indian Independence League “I am writing to you on the eve of a long journey by air and who knows an accident may not overtake me”. (the message indicates Netaji’s plan for disappearance)

• In the evening of 17th August 1945 at 5.45 PM, Netaji took leave of his Staff at Saigon Airport and boarded the Japanese Bomber Plane with General Shidei and Col. Habibur Rehman. Plane reached Dalat, Headquarter of Field Marshal Terauchi – the Supreme Commander of Japanese Quantung Army. Thus, Netaji and General Shidei were separated from others. Nobody went to Taihoku, hence there was no Plane Crash. (Taiwan Government has confirmed that there was no plane crash on Matsuyama Airport of Taihoku from 14.08.1945 to 25.10.1945.)

18th Aug. 1945


22nd Aug. 1945 • On 18th August 1945, Lt. General Hikosaburo met Russian Major General Shelakor to work out peaceful surrender modalities of Japanese Quantung Army and safe handover of Netaji.

• “So called death” of Netaji in a plane crash at Taihoku ( as decided, in advance, to be declared after his escape to Russian territory), while Netaji was very much present in the vicinity of Saigon on 18th August 1945.

• On 19th August 1945, a meeting took place between Ho-Chi- Minh (the Famous Vietnamese Revolutionary (later Head of North Vietnam, known as ‘Uncle Ho’) and renowned Chinese General Liu-Po-Cheng at Saigon in which Netaji was also present. American Intelligence officer and War correspondent of Chicago Tribune, Mr. Alfred Wagg and Bishop of Dalat saw Netaji in Saigon, after declared death. Mr. Wagg also took some photographs of Netaji and later met with Nehru, Gandhi, Sarat Bose and others and told that he saw Subhas at Saigon, after the news of Plane Crash.(other reference: Sunday Observer, London dated 2.9.1945)

• Up to 21 August 1945, Netaji stayed at Dalat, 10 miles away from Saigon, the Headquarter of Japanese Quantung Army in South East Asia with Field Marshal Terauchi.

• On 22 Aug. 1945, Japanese Quantung Army, led by General Otozo, finally, surrendered to General Alexander Varsilovsky of Russian Red Army in Manchurian Capital, Harbin, as pre-arranged plan because both Japan and USSR did not want Anglo-American entry in Manchurian Region.

23rd Aug. 1945 • On 23 August 1945, Netaji reached Dairen (Manchuria) at 1.30 p.m. from Saigon in a Japanese Bomber Plane along with General Shidei, General Otozo and Lt. General Hikosaburo. They entered Russian occupied territory ‘Mukden’ with General Shidei and others in a jeep. After 3 hours jeep returned to Dairen and informed to the pilot of the plane who then flew back to Tokyo.

• Netaji was received at Mukden by Russian Emissary and Kato Kachu – the Consulate of Provisional Government of Free India at Omsk office in Russia. USSR had allowed a center of Provisional Government of Free India at Omsk in spite of being an ally to USA and UK in Second World War. Ref: (i)WO 203/4673HS/SEAC/591 dated 19.10.1945 Public Records Office, London (ii) File INA 273 Exhibit 242, page-12

• On 23 August 1945, General Isoda informed Shri Sengupta (Bose’s aide) “Don’t worry, His Excellency Subhas Chandra Bose is in safe custody”

• On 23 August 1945, Japanese Broadcasting Agency declared death of Netaji in plane crash. This declaration was made after ensuring Bose’s entry to Russian Territory.

• Field Marshal Wavell wrote in his diary “Japanese Announcement of Subhas Chandra Bose’s death in an Air- Crash…I suspect it very much…it is just what should be given out if he (Subhas) meant to go underground.”

• Supreme Allied Commander South East Asia, Admiral Mountbatten constituted a team comprising his most able Secret and Intelligence officers: Intelligence Bureau Deputy Director –Finney and his assistants Davis, A K Roy, Kalipad Dey, and “Rai Bahadur” Bakshi Badrinath to catch Bose alive. The team, after intensive investigations, reported that “Bose has gone underground to reappear at the correct psychological moment.” Reference: (i) Doc. No. 10005/3/GSI (b),The British library, Oriental and India Office Collection, London (ii) American Intelligence Reports about the activities of Netaji during17-25 August 1945 and (iii) Letters from General Mc Aurthur to American President Truman during17-31 August 1945

• Again it was a big slap on the British by Netaji Subhas Chandra Bose. Philip Finney (who knew Subhas Chandra Bose from the days as Superintendent of Police in Bengal) was sure that Subhas has made his way to Russian occupied Territory. But the British allowed the wide circulation of Bose’s death only to keep Indians’ morale low at that time.

• Note of Sir R. F. Mudie (Home Member of Wavell Govt.) dated 23.8.45 to Sir E. M. Jenkins (PS to Viceroy Wavell) for consideration of British Cabinet on “Treatment of Bose” is a clear cut evidence that Netaji did not die in any Plane Crash on 18th August 1945. It goes like this:

Mudie proposed :

One of the most difficult questions that will confront Home Department in the near future is the treatment of Subhas Chandra Bose… Indian masses have deep admiration and respect for Subhas Bose …

1. Bring him back to India and try him either for waging war or under the enemy agents’ ordinance.

2. Have him tried by a court in Burma or Malaya for waging war against the King in that country.

3. Have him tried by a military court outside India.

4. Intern him in India.

5. Intern him in some other British possession, e.g. Seychelles Islands

6. Leave him where he is and do not ask for his surrender.

7. I do not think that there is any chance of Bose being hanged if he is tried in India. The pressure for his release would be too great; and also his trial would result in great publicity for his doings, motives, etc.

8. It is extremely unlikely that the Government of Burma, which is engaged in appeasing the Burma National Army, would agree to try Bose and even more likely that if they did, they would hang him. The Government of Malaya might possibly have no such scruples and we might get a hanging if His Majesty’s Government agreed to ignore agitation in India and Parliament however strong. But a trial in Singapore would cause almost as much agitation in this country as a trial here, unless it was held in camera and no news released till after his execution. But in that case we would be accused of judicial murder.

9. In many ways the easiest course would be to leave him where he is and not ask for his release. He might, of course, in certain circumstances, be welcomed by the Russians. This course would raise fewest immediate political difficulties, but the security authorities consider that in certain circumstances his presence in Russia would be so dangerous to rule it out altogether.

10. The choice seems to be between deporting and interning Bose outside India or trying him in India and commuting the death sentence. The two might be combined and Bose deported (or “transported”) after conviction.

Yours sincerely,

R.F. Mudie

(Ref: Transfer of Power, Vol. VI, Pages 138-139)


28th  Aug.


Sept. & Oct. 1945


1945  to

Feb. 1946


(Ref: British Intelligent Report- PRO.WO.203/804 from HQ Army to SACSEAI2060.ISUM No. 21)

(Ref: Top Secret File No.  273/INA  Document C-4, Part VI,  National Archive, New Delhi and                File No. 10/Misc/INA/Page 38-39 handed over to Shahanawaj Committee)

Dear Mr. Attlee,

I have come to know from a reliable source that Subhas Chandra Bose, your war criminal, has been allowed to enter Russian territory by Stalin. This is a clear treachery and betrayal of faith by the Russians. As Russia has been an ally of the British-Americans, it should not have been done. Please take note of it and do what you consider proper and fit.

Yours sincerely,

Jawaharlal Nehru

Ref: (i) Shri P. C. Kar – the Radio Monitor of then Bengal Governor Sir Richard G. Casey, (ii) PM Office File No. 870/11/P/16/92-POL page 21-22) requisitioned by the Mukherjee Commission again and again but not provided by the Govt. of India and (iii) London correspondent of ‘Dainik Sevika’, dt.18th March 1946, a daily published from Malaya.

“… In many cities, there are Muslims who support Subhas than Jinnah … We are sitting on a volcano that is about to erupt.”

“…The Indian Army in India is not obeying the British officers. In these conditions if we have to rule India for a long time, we have to keep a permanent British army for a long time in a vast country of four hundred millions. We have no such army…”

March 1946

April 1946

June &July 1946

Aug. 1946


Dec. 1946

(Ref: Communication between Viceroy Wavell and India Office, London)

Ref: (i) Confirmation by Shri Goga (son of Shri Abani Mukherjee) to Dr. Satyanarayan Sinha (former Indian Ambassador to Russia)  (ii) Confirmation to Press at Delhi by Ms. Swetlana (daughter of Stalin) (iii) PMO Files 2(64)/56-66-PM (Vol.III, page no. 112)   

15 Aug. 1947

Jan. 1948



Oct, 1949

[1st week]




Link [1]


We Lost Netaji Only for Congress (Nehru) & Communist Party

Facebook Comments
  1. Link : https://www.facebook.com/notes/162973517131460/

Source URL: http://ultadin.com/2015/12/30/we-lost-netaji-only-for-congress-nehru-communist-party/